Thanks Bill, for having the courage to say 'we are hooped' and not proffer 'solutions'. We have all been conditioned to believe that somehow 8 billion humans, if 'properly' informed, and with the appropriate 'leadership', will rationally, coherently and magically self-organize to 'solve' any predicament. We believe that even though there is no evidence that that has ever happened.
As John Gray wrote in Straw Dogs: “The destruction of the natural world is not the result of global capitalism, industrialization, Western civilization, or any flaw in human institutions. It is a consequence of the evolutionary success of an exceptionally rapacious primate... The mass of mankind is ruled not by its own intermittent moral sensations, still less by self-interest, but by the needs of the moment. It seems fated to wreck the balance of life on Earth — and thereby to be the agent of its own destruction. What could be more hopeless than placing the Earth in the charge of this exceptionally destructive species?"
And in any case, there's pretty compelling evidence that we have no 'free will' to do anything even if we were somehow able to change everyone's mind to agree on what needs 'doing'. Science demonstrates quite conclusively that all our behaviour is conditioned by our biology and our culture — it is already 'determined' (though not predictable or 'determinable').
Best we can hope for, I think, is to come to accept our bewildered animal nature and the inevitable and accelerating collapse of our well-intentioned 'civilization', and try to live our lives as fully and joyfully as the circumstances of each moment allow us. We may be called 'doomers' now, but eventually I think we'll be understood to be realists, and, hopefully, 'joyful pessimists'.
You say: "Thanks Bill, for having the courage to say 'we are hooped' and not proffer 'solutions'." Normally a commenter complains when a writer doesn't offer solutions. In this case, the author implies possible solutions, at least what we should've done or should be doing, but says we're wired not to do them. This is a very reality-based assessment. However, that can lead to cynicism, one of the human traits the author mentions as responsible for our predicament. Anyway, both you & Dr. Rees are correct in not futilely holding out unwarranted hope.
For myself, I will continue to live the low consumption, low carbon footprint, pro-environmental lifestyle I have always lived & enjoyed, wishing others would try it, too, but knowing full well such wishes are in vain.
The thing is, that lifestyle (which I share to a degree), is not sustainable, merely less damaging. Even lifestyles in countries that have a much lower footprint are not sustainable. There are degrees of damage and we can extend the period that civilisation/modernity but can never make it sustainable.
We'd have to reduce our overall population as well as consumption. And actually in many countries, mostly developed nations, birth rate has gone well below replacement level, & population is starting to decline. This trend needs to spread throughout the world, contrary to the preachings of the likes of Elon Musk. This has to be accompanied by an array of measures to reduce carbon emissions & environmental destruction, & it must be global & led by governments, corporations & other influencers, to not only reduce consumption, pollution & waste by those most responsible for it, but also to make it much easier for the public to adopt a more sustainable lifestyle. That would not only extend the period in which civilization is able to persist, but also make it possible for some ecosystem recovery as we continue to reduce population & consumption & make technological advancements that could theoretically accelerate recovery.
Yes, but I wonder what the goal should be. Should it be to extend civilisation for some arbitrary period of time (in which case, what should that period be?) or to stop the destruction of the environment as quickly as possible? They are contradictory goals.
Many thanks, Tristan -- I appreciate the boost and hope you are correct that the neo-Malthusian (I've been called much worse) trope is finally dissolving.
I've been called Malthusian also, as a reward for promoting human reproductive restraint.
The guy who called me that has created offspring, and also promotes "abundance" philosophy, so he seems biased for human narcissism, and against human restraint.
Interestingly, he is a professor, so it is strange he seems to violate intellectual humility and rigor, while teaching anti-environmental sentiments as a professional educator.
Additionally, he works in an organization that promotes responsible budgeting for the USA federal government. So he preaches government financial restraint, but is opposed to pro-environment population restraint. 'Restraint and basic math for thee, but not for me.'
Having heard your reasoning on number of YouTube videos and now your Substack, I want to thank you for you for your clear and cogent analysis of our predicament. As one biologist put it long ago, our fatal flaw is we are too numerous, too clever and too greedy. Retired now, I made my living as a jet charter pilot, moving rich people around the planet burning insane amounts of kerosene while being fully aware of the damage this activity was doing. Nothing is going to stop our species from driving full speed to collapse.
Perhaps another important point is how overshoot is largely obscured within the MTI imagination as a result of trading relationships with rich developed countries capturing and appropriating the natural wealth of poor developing countries in order to sustain consumption - population overshoot with much of the anthropic effects of overshoot externalised via internecine land conflicts, absolute poverty, famine, forced displacement, modern day slavery, indentured labour, neglible environmental standards, toxic waste tailings and other byproducts of industrial processes.
In other words, the maladaptive relationship between the MTI core and the nonMTI periphery. Or in other words, neocolonialism which is structured within the UN and their Sustainable Development Goals, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund and the WTO.
The Dominant versus the Subservient with the dominant externalising the real world effects of overshoot to the subservient in order to create the mirage of abundance and infinite growth on a finite planet.
Very important point that goes to the inherent structural violence of capitalism and it's most recent coca-colonialist manifestation - globalisation. Yep, collapse has happened many times before, but this time its global. There are no 'lifeboats'.
Currently the Subservient are in a high gradient zero sum game because they are already hitting capacity limits although ones created anthropically rather ecologically.
The Dominant, I don't think are in a high gradient zero sum game more between low and medium.
I guess when the Dominant are in a high (hard) zero sum game, then we know the global system is collapsing.
In terms of lifeboats, communities in the UK are developing alternative survival systems.
So perhaps, despite being ecological realists, neo-Malthusians are persecuted because they threaten the ecological idealist mirage of abundance and infinite growth on a finite planet and perhaps more importantly threaten the
2nd thermodynamic law 🤔
maximum power 🤔
maximum entropy 🤔
natural selection 🤔
hierarchical relationship between the Dominant and the Subservient despite this persecution epitomising eco(spheric sui)cide?! 😊🥴
This is a very strong piece, and it’s good to see a lifelong scientist confronting essential truth about the human predicament, but there are always going to be omissions in a broad overview like this.
Stupidity is an easy epithet to use about humans, but the more correct term is “ultrasocial,” and the ultimate expression of ruling ultrasociality is the corporation, whether private or state. There is no record of any human controlling the suicidal role of corporations, especially not in the academia that Mr. Rees spent his life in.
Corporations control human affairs, whether in Gaza and Sudan or Substack or your backyard, and bury humanist ideals, over and over, place after place.
What can humans do about this? A bake sale, a nice essay, a backyard garden, a walk in the woods, a rescue of an animal, a book to read, a singalong? Sure, individuals can do the microscopic prosocial act, but at the collective level, the supertankers are in the water, the bombs are being constructed, the legal fictions are being reinforced, and the profits are being reaped. Everywhere.
This fatal discontinuity was true back in the halcyon 60s, and is exponentially more true in our present moment.
Thanks Bill. Cogently expressed as always. Recently, I had the opportunity to present on a 'Futures' panel discussion at a 'Downshift' music/arts/ideas festival where I immediately outed myself as a 'doomer' and then told the assembled youth that climate/ecological/civilisational collapse was inevitable - to which I received rousing applause.
I believe the neo-malthusian trope is wearing quite thin these days I think, and your efforts among others, have been most useful in fostering an emerging zeitgeist which is more closely aligned with the reality of our overshoot predicament.
The heroic and tragic stoicism of the Titanic's band-leader, Wallace Hartley, may serve as an example for us all.
Excellent article Bill, have been devouring your Youtube interviews over the last few years as one of the few sane voices in the barrage of noise we call civilisation.
one of the biggest issues that you brushed up against in point 19, is if I restrict my use of a resources, the next group will come along anyway ad take it, so I may as well... trawler ships for instance... It probably happened 30,000 years ago when someone noticed that there were less mammoths and suggested that the group not kill so many, they made an attempt to heed this advice; but the neighboring group had not heard the suggestion or even cared to agree — the mammoths were killed anyway and sent extinct. This mindset of 'if I don't they will' is driving AI and military expansions... and exploitation of natural resources...
Thanks so much for putting the case in a nutshell Dr Rees.
For the sake of non-Canadians, here is internet definition of "hooped:" "Containing hoops. (western Canada, slang) beset with unfortunate circumstances that seem difficult or impossible to overcome; screwed."
Thank you William for your insightful and brilliant perspective. I have watched many of your video interviews and each time I am moved by your vast knowledge and compassion.
I hope you know that you’re not alone in your way of thinking. If only we could spare people like you from the pain and suffering that is upon us all :)
Thanks Bill, for having the courage to say 'we are hooped' and not proffer 'solutions'. We have all been conditioned to believe that somehow 8 billion humans, if 'properly' informed, and with the appropriate 'leadership', will rationally, coherently and magically self-organize to 'solve' any predicament. We believe that even though there is no evidence that that has ever happened.
As John Gray wrote in Straw Dogs: “The destruction of the natural world is not the result of global capitalism, industrialization, Western civilization, or any flaw in human institutions. It is a consequence of the evolutionary success of an exceptionally rapacious primate... The mass of mankind is ruled not by its own intermittent moral sensations, still less by self-interest, but by the needs of the moment. It seems fated to wreck the balance of life on Earth — and thereby to be the agent of its own destruction. What could be more hopeless than placing the Earth in the charge of this exceptionally destructive species?"
And in any case, there's pretty compelling evidence that we have no 'free will' to do anything even if we were somehow able to change everyone's mind to agree on what needs 'doing'. Science demonstrates quite conclusively that all our behaviour is conditioned by our biology and our culture — it is already 'determined' (though not predictable or 'determinable').
Best we can hope for, I think, is to come to accept our bewildered animal nature and the inevitable and accelerating collapse of our well-intentioned 'civilization', and try to live our lives as fully and joyfully as the circumstances of each moment allow us. We may be called 'doomers' now, but eventually I think we'll be understood to be realists, and, hopefully, 'joyful pessimists'.
You say: "Thanks Bill, for having the courage to say 'we are hooped' and not proffer 'solutions'." Normally a commenter complains when a writer doesn't offer solutions. In this case, the author implies possible solutions, at least what we should've done or should be doing, but says we're wired not to do them. This is a very reality-based assessment. However, that can lead to cynicism, one of the human traits the author mentions as responsible for our predicament. Anyway, both you & Dr. Rees are correct in not futilely holding out unwarranted hope.
For myself, I will continue to live the low consumption, low carbon footprint, pro-environmental lifestyle I have always lived & enjoyed, wishing others would try it, too, but knowing full well such wishes are in vain.
The thing is, that lifestyle (which I share to a degree), is not sustainable, merely less damaging. Even lifestyles in countries that have a much lower footprint are not sustainable. There are degrees of damage and we can extend the period that civilisation/modernity but can never make it sustainable.
We'd have to reduce our overall population as well as consumption. And actually in many countries, mostly developed nations, birth rate has gone well below replacement level, & population is starting to decline. This trend needs to spread throughout the world, contrary to the preachings of the likes of Elon Musk. This has to be accompanied by an array of measures to reduce carbon emissions & environmental destruction, & it must be global & led by governments, corporations & other influencers, to not only reduce consumption, pollution & waste by those most responsible for it, but also to make it much easier for the public to adopt a more sustainable lifestyle. That would not only extend the period in which civilization is able to persist, but also make it possible for some ecosystem recovery as we continue to reduce population & consumption & make technological advancements that could theoretically accelerate recovery.
Yes, but I wonder what the goal should be. Should it be to extend civilisation for some arbitrary period of time (in which case, what should that period be?) or to stop the destruction of the environment as quickly as possible? They are contradictory goals.
Doomers are realists; all we've done is ignored the elephant population in the reserve and decided not to cull them. We are Dumbo.
All everyone needs to know about global warming https://fasteddynz.substack.com/p/the-three-pillars-of-bullshit
see #13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, above. That's advice to other readers, I don't expect you to get it
Many thanks, Tristan -- I appreciate the boost and hope you are correct that the neo-Malthusian (I've been called much worse) trope is finally dissolving.
I've been called Malthusian also, as a reward for promoting human reproductive restraint.
The guy who called me that has created offspring, and also promotes "abundance" philosophy, so he seems biased for human narcissism, and against human restraint.
Interestingly, he is a professor, so it is strange he seems to violate intellectual humility and rigor, while teaching anti-environmental sentiments as a professional educator.
Additionally, he works in an organization that promotes responsible budgeting for the USA federal government. So he preaches government financial restraint, but is opposed to pro-environment population restraint. 'Restraint and basic math for thee, but not for me.'
Having heard your reasoning on number of YouTube videos and now your Substack, I want to thank you for you for your clear and cogent analysis of our predicament. As one biologist put it long ago, our fatal flaw is we are too numerous, too clever and too greedy. Retired now, I made my living as a jet charter pilot, moving rich people around the planet burning insane amounts of kerosene while being fully aware of the damage this activity was doing. Nothing is going to stop our species from driving full speed to collapse.
Perhaps another important point is how overshoot is largely obscured within the MTI imagination as a result of trading relationships with rich developed countries capturing and appropriating the natural wealth of poor developing countries in order to sustain consumption - population overshoot with much of the anthropic effects of overshoot externalised via internecine land conflicts, absolute poverty, famine, forced displacement, modern day slavery, indentured labour, neglible environmental standards, toxic waste tailings and other byproducts of industrial processes.
In other words, the maladaptive relationship between the MTI core and the nonMTI periphery. Or in other words, neocolonialism which is structured within the UN and their Sustainable Development Goals, the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund and the WTO.
The Dominant versus the Subservient with the dominant externalising the real world effects of overshoot to the subservient in order to create the mirage of abundance and infinite growth on a finite planet.
Very important point that goes to the inherent structural violence of capitalism and it's most recent coca-colonialist manifestation - globalisation. Yep, collapse has happened many times before, but this time its global. There are no 'lifeboats'.
Currently the Subservient are in a high gradient zero sum game because they are already hitting capacity limits although ones created anthropically rather ecologically.
The Dominant, I don't think are in a high gradient zero sum game more between low and medium.
I guess when the Dominant are in a high (hard) zero sum game, then we know the global system is collapsing.
In terms of lifeboats, communities in the UK are developing alternative survival systems.
https://www.lowimpact.org/categories/economy/commons-economy
I think younger generations will increasingly move in this direction.
Some eco-author recently referred to self sustainable communities as lifeboats.
Yes - Resilient communities can provide some measure of socio-ecological justice as the ship goes down.
So perhaps, despite being ecological realists, neo-Malthusians are persecuted because they threaten the ecological idealist mirage of abundance and infinite growth on a finite planet and perhaps more importantly threaten the
2nd thermodynamic law 🤔
maximum power 🤔
maximum entropy 🤔
natural selection 🤔
hierarchical relationship between the Dominant and the Subservient despite this persecution epitomising eco(spheric sui)cide?! 😊🥴
This is a very strong piece, and it’s good to see a lifelong scientist confronting essential truth about the human predicament, but there are always going to be omissions in a broad overview like this.
Stupidity is an easy epithet to use about humans, but the more correct term is “ultrasocial,” and the ultimate expression of ruling ultrasociality is the corporation, whether private or state. There is no record of any human controlling the suicidal role of corporations, especially not in the academia that Mr. Rees spent his life in.
Corporations control human affairs, whether in Gaza and Sudan or Substack or your backyard, and bury humanist ideals, over and over, place after place.
What can humans do about this? A bake sale, a nice essay, a backyard garden, a walk in the woods, a rescue of an animal, a book to read, a singalong? Sure, individuals can do the microscopic prosocial act, but at the collective level, the supertankers are in the water, the bombs are being constructed, the legal fictions are being reinforced, and the profits are being reaped. Everywhere.
This fatal discontinuity was true back in the halcyon 60s, and is exponentially more true in our present moment.
Thanks Bill. Cogently expressed as always. Recently, I had the opportunity to present on a 'Futures' panel discussion at a 'Downshift' music/arts/ideas festival where I immediately outed myself as a 'doomer' and then told the assembled youth that climate/ecological/civilisational collapse was inevitable - to which I received rousing applause.
I believe the neo-malthusian trope is wearing quite thin these days I think, and your efforts among others, have been most useful in fostering an emerging zeitgeist which is more closely aligned with the reality of our overshoot predicament.
The heroic and tragic stoicism of the Titanic's band-leader, Wallace Hartley, may serve as an example for us all.
Cheers.
"Humanity will be much reduced". The understatement of the century (with "hooped" running a close second)!
Excellent article Bill, have been devouring your Youtube interviews over the last few years as one of the few sane voices in the barrage of noise we call civilisation.
"Selected out", love it.
What a great summary. I will be sharing this widely, Dr. Rees.
Bravo Bill.
In short, we can't have infinite growth on a finite planet, and one is delusional if one thinks they can.
So why do we, as a species, persist with this delusion? Because our maladaptive biology coopts our imagination to say we can.
So whether it is
fiscal overshoot
debt overshoot
consumption overshoot
population overshoot
ecological overshoot
as a species we seem to be very good at one thing, overshoot!
Maladaptive biology + imagination = overshoot.
So how do we create an adaptive biology via our imagination?
one of the biggest issues that you brushed up against in point 19, is if I restrict my use of a resources, the next group will come along anyway ad take it, so I may as well... trawler ships for instance... It probably happened 30,000 years ago when someone noticed that there were less mammoths and suggested that the group not kill so many, they made an attempt to heed this advice; but the neighboring group had not heard the suggestion or even cared to agree — the mammoths were killed anyway and sent extinct. This mindset of 'if I don't they will' is driving AI and military expansions... and exploitation of natural resources...
Yes, it's 'standard' behaviour -- the psychological incentives push us in the wrong (for the ecosphere) direction.
I appreciate your taking the time to comment and appreciate your dilemma respecting your family.
Thanks so much for putting the case in a nutshell Dr Rees.
For the sake of non-Canadians, here is internet definition of "hooped:" "Containing hoops. (western Canada, slang) beset with unfortunate circumstances that seem difficult or impossible to overcome; screwed."
“Hooped” Thank you sir. I assumed something of the sort from context.
I’m deeply grateful for Dr Rees’s substack and the knowledgeable commentary here.
Thank you William for your insightful and brilliant perspective. I have watched many of your video interviews and each time I am moved by your vast knowledge and compassion.
I hope you know that you’re not alone in your way of thinking. If only we could spare people like you from the pain and suffering that is upon us all :)
Thank you, Jon. It's encouraging to know there are increasing numbers of us paddling the canoe even if against a strengthening current.
I keep telling everyone we are living in civilizational hospice.
Another angle I think we should consider is the class war underway, that underlies the poly crisis.
I used that analogy comparing the dynamics on the sinking Titanic to the class war on land.
https://kevinhester.live/2023/04/27/class-war-on-the-sinking-titanic/